This video about Detroit — our history and bike infrastructrure — is really one of the best and we’re not saying that just because we’re in it. Nic Laporte created a well-balanced overview of where we’ve been and where we’re heading.
The video also has us talking about the history of stop streets and stop signs, which is something we plan to write more about. We believe this is an important perspective, especially when it comes to bicycling and Idaho stop laws.
Below are comments we gave before Detroit City Council:
We are continuing to advocate for the city council to adopt a Complete Streets ordinance.
Complete Streets are those that are designed for all users – motorists, transit users, pedestrians, people with disabilities, bicyclists, and more. Complete Streets make it easier for everyone to safely travel along and across the street.
We began our ordinance work 15 years ago and much has changed. Back then, we saw the ordinance as a tool to get the city to build Complete Streets.
While we weren’t successful in passing that initial ordinance, we were successful in pushing for change. Detroit now has a Complete Streets Department and an excellent Streets for People Transportation Plan. It’s built some amazing Complete Street projects including streetscapes. Thousands of speed humps and other traffic calming features have been installed. And, DPW has been very successful tapping into state and federal funding to make this happen.
So why do we need an ordinance today?
We believe a Complete Streets ordinance can codify what the city is doing today, while giving the city more leverage in getting the state and county to do the same.
We don’t expect the ordinance to change course or have any major effect on the DPW budget. Those changes have already occurred.
Still, we believe this ordinance is as important as ever.
As we’re seeing right now in Washington DC, a new administration can abruptly shift a transportation department’s direction away from best practices. An ordinance could dissuade this from happening in Detroit.
Detroit had 130 traffic fatalities in 2023 with 28% being pedestrians, so clearly there is a continued need to emphasize safer street designs.
We believe an ordinance would help keep us on that path.
The Detroit Historical Museum has an interesting photo in their collection. It’s a group shot of the Detroit Rambler Bike Club from 1896. What makes it so unique is the Black bicyclist standing prominently in the center behind the club banner.
We shared this photo with Andrew Ritchie, author of Major Taylor: The Extraordinary Career of a Champion Bicycle Racer. He said, “Given the League of American Wheelmen Black-exclusion that had taken place officially in 1894, the Detroit club is definitely making a pointed statement.”
We have been trying to gain more information on this photo. Unfortunately the Historical Museum does not have the key identifying the club members.
However, it appears the Black bicyclist (#16) may be “Trainer Edwards” of the 1894 Rambler racing team, but that’s all we know so far. We have not been able to find an Edwards listed in either the 1890 or 1900 Census, nor is he in the 1895 Polk Directory.
#33 might be the 1894 team manager, George H. Formhals. Formhals is listed in the 1895 Polk Directory as the general manager for the Gormully & Jeffrey Manufacturing Company which made Rambler bikes in Chicago. They had a store at 1275 Woodward (formerly 201 Woodward), but the building is no longer there.
Rambler bikes were very popular in Detroit. Their 1895 advertisement claimed that one-eighth of all bikes in Detroit were Ramblers, but we haven’t verified that claim.
In 1896, Gormully & Jeffrey gave away gold souvenirs to those who rode 3,000 miles on a Rambler bike. Each week, riders would have to show their cyclometer to their local Rambler agent. The total miles ridden were tallied across the country.
Detroit won in a landslide and got the “$400 in gold” prize. The highest individual mileage was over 15,000 miles though we don’t know if that was a Detroiter.
The Detroit Historical Society does have a second Rambler group photo from 1896 with some riders in both images.
There are also records of a Rambler bike club in 1887, which would have been riding high wheelers. Louis “Birdie” Munger was a First Lietenant. Munger started his own bicycle company in Chicago, which led him to befriend, coach and support Major Taylor. It’s unclear if Munger’s involvement with that earlier club somehow influenced these later incarnations.
Sante Fe New Mexican, May 12, 1897
Rambler Automobiles?
There is a connection between the Rambler bikes and Rambler cars.
In 1900, Gormully & Jeffrey was sold to the American Bicycle Company. Thomas B. Jeffrey started a new company to make Rambler automobiles. In 1916, this new company was sold and became the Nash Motors Company, which in 1954, became part of the American Motors Corporation. Ramblers were built in the U.S. through 1969, and in Mexico through 1983.
A new report compares Michigan with five other Midwestern states.
Walking, accessibility, biking, and transit saw considerable improvements in policy and funding with the adoption of the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. An often overlooked piece of those legislative changes was the creation of a new document: the Vulnerable Road User Safety Assessment (VRUSA, also pronounced Ver-roo-suh, for short).
The VRUSA is a tool to evaluate how a state Department of Transportation (DOT) understands the issue of traffic violence among people who walk, roll, and bike. It also documents what state DOTs are doing to address and improve the safety of vulnerable road users.
While every state is supposed to follow the same guidance from the Federal Highway Administration with developing their own VRUSA, that does not always look the same in practice. These documents are essentially self assessments — the onus is on states to evaluate themselves and their efforts.
In creating their VRUSAs, each state needed to detail their efforts to protect vulnerable road users in five key areas:
Overview of VRU Safety Performance – what trends exist in VRU crashes and what progress is the state DOT making to address this?
Summary of Quantitative Analysis – what data and methodology did the state DOT use to identify high-risk areas of VRUs?
Summary of Consultation – who did the state DOT consult with in the community and what solutions did these individuals or groups offer?
Program of Projects or Strategies – what specific steps is the state DOT taking to reduce VRU crashes?
Safe System Approach (SSA) – how was the Safe System Approach incorporated into the state DOT’s VRUSA?
The first major deadline for states to complete and submit their VRUSA was November 2023. After that, states are expected to update the document as part of their Strategic Highway Safety Plan update, which must be completed every five years.
Thanks to funding from the RE-AMP Network, we were able to study this further in partnership with BikeWalkKC, 1000 Friends of Iowa, 1000 Friends of Wisconsin, Bike Cleveland and Transportation Riders United. We analyzed and compared the VRUSAs of Michigan and five other states and compiled our work into the findings below:
Ways that the Federal Highway Administration can strengthen its guidance on how state DOTs develop their VRUSAs,
Details on how each state completed (or didn’t complete) the required parts of a VRUSA, and
Recommendations on how those states can do more to support the needs of vulnerable road users in the future.
Additionally, the report makes recommendations for how each state DOT can do more to support the needs of vulnerable road users. What did this look like for Michigan?
MDOT’s program of projects and strategies should address the changes needed to make VRU safety a key criteria in road project funding prioritization (e.g. implementation of Virginia’s SMART SCALE program).
MDOT should identify existing projects and strategies that are a barrier to improving VRU safety.
In light of these points, the question becomes: “How can advocates in other states use this approach to push their state DOTs to do more for Vulnerable Road Users?” Examples include:
Draw attention to dangerous corridors. Use the report to highlight the dangers for people who walk, roll, and bike along corridors identified as harmful. Invite your state DOT staff and/or local media to do a walk audit along those corridors so they understand the challenges from the pedestrian perspective.
Share the VRUSA with local leaders. Make sure that the elected leaders and staff of communities that are overrepresented in your state’s VRUSA know and understand why their community is unsafe for vulnerable road users and what can be done to address it. That can help to strengthen your efforts to get the state DOT to do more.
Push state DOTs to take steps they have missed or ignored. What the VRUSA says or does not say is a reflection of what a state DOT has done or not done. Advocates can help the public understand that the poor safety outcomes may speak to the need for additional steps. In Missouri, for example, BikeWalkKC is using the VRUSA to push MoDOT to develop a statewide active transportation plan (one of only five states that has not taken this crucial step).
In publishing this report, we hope to demystify the Vulnerable Road User Safety Assessment for active transportation advocates across the country. The goal is to make it easier for people to understand what their state DOT is (or is not) doing for its most vulnerable road users. It serves as a tool to help people push their state DOTs to do better.
The Detroit Greenways Coalition is joining communities around the world in observing the World Day of Remembrance for Road Traffic Victims, taking place on November 17th, 2024. This annual observance serves as an opportunity to honor the lives lost and affected by road traffic crashes, raise awareness about road safety, and advocate for safer, more sustainable transportation systems for all.
The Detroit Greenways Coalition, a non-profit organization dedicated to the expansion and improvement of the city’s network of safe walking, biking, and rolling pathways, recognizes the vital need for systemic change to prevent road traffic fatalities and injuries in Detroit and beyond. This day serves as a reminder of the human cost of unsafe roadways and underscores the importance of a holistic approach to transportation that prioritizes safety, equity, and environmental sustainability.
“We mourn the lives lost on our streets, and we stand with the families, friends, and communities who are affected by traffic violence,” said Todd Scott, Executive Director of the Detroit Greenways Coalition. “In Detroit, too many people are impacted by preventable crashes, and we are committed to advocating for policies and infrastructure that protect the most vulnerable road users, including pedestrians, cyclists, and people with disabilities.”
The World Day of Remembrance for Road Traffic Victims, which began in 1995, is observed in over 50 countries and calls for action on issues of road safety, justice for victims, and accountability for those who contribute to the epidemic of road traffic injuries and fatalities. In Detroit, the Coalition is amplifying its efforts to support Vision Zero goals—an initiative aimed at reducing all traffic fatalities to zero.
“We must work together to create safe streets that are designed for people, not just cars. We’re optimistic that the $62.5 million Detroit has received in Safe Streets for All funding will help address the most dangerous streets and intersections,” said Scott. “However, Detroit’s 1,285 road fatalities during the past decade (with nearly one-third being vulnerable road users) is a stark reminder that this work is far from done.”
We submitted the below comments on MDOT’s 2025-2029 Five-Year Transportation Plan. This year we did not have any comments specific to Detroit projects within the plan. However, we did ask how this plan supports and helps meet MDOT’s Toward Zero Deaths goal and Governor Gretchen Whitmer’s Carbon Neutrality pledge. We’d note that the plan’s cover includes a photo of 14th Street construction in Corktopwn that removed the bike lanes.
Safety
The MDOT trunkline safety goal of zero fatalities and serious injuries by 2050 will not be met by reliance on “several safety initiatives and strategies.” (Page 23) We ask for a more sober assessment that this goal will not be achieved without fundamental changes in how MDOT prioritizes, funds and designs its trunklines while also making investments that encourage modeshift to public transit and active transportation. The latter is critically necessary for MDOT to reach its safety goal, yet we don’t see this mentioned in the plan, even in Public Transportation Program Impacts. (Page 19).
We ask that you show the required annual performance targets to get MDOT to zero by 2050. If you can project pavement and bridge condition through 2040 then there’s no reason why safety can’t be given this similar forward looking graph.
MDOT’s prioritization of safety is not apparent from the provided project list, including the proposed HSIP list. Is MDOT prioritizing safety projects in the high-injury network? By far, Wayne County has more trunkline fatalities and serious injuries than any other Michigan county, yet no proposed HSIP projects are listed for it.
Carbon Neutrality
This plan has a modest mention of MDOT’s Carbon Reduction Strategy (using a broken hyperlink) but doesn’t show how these strategies affect the provided project list. Do these projects reduce carbon emissions and will they get the state to carbon neutrality by 2050?
Similar to our safety comments, we want to see carbon emissions performance targets through 2050. We want to know where we are at today and what changes need to be made to get us to zero.
And as we noted earlier, modeshift to public transit and active transportation must be clearly called out in the plan as a fundamental safety and carbon neutrality strategy.